Completed
Case Information
Filed: September 10, 2026
Assigned to:
Hector Gonzalez
Referred to:
—
Nature of Suit: Habeas Corpus - Alien Detainee
Cause:
28:2241 Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus (federa
Completed: September 30, 2026
Last Activity:
September 30, 2026
Parties:
View All Parties →
Docket Entries
#1
Sep 10, 2026
PETITION for Writ of Habeas Corpus filing fee $ 5, receipt number BNYEDC-20618971, filed by Ruben Lucas. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibits A to C, # 2 Civil Cover Sheet) (Bautista-Munoz, Ma. Nessa) (Entered: 09/10/2026)
Main Document:
Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus
#2
Sep 11, 2026
This attorney case opening filing has been checked for quality control. See the attachment for corrections that were made, if any. (SDM) (Entered: 09/11/2026)
Main Document:
Quality Control Check - Attorney Case Opening
Sep 11, 2026
Quality Control Check - Summons
Sep 11, 2026
Order to Show Cause (463)
Sep 11, 2026
Case Assigned/Reassigned
Sep 11, 2026
Case Assigned to Judge Hector Gonzalez. Please download and review the Individual Practices of the assigned Judges, located on our website. Attorneys are responsible for providing courtesy copies to judges where their Individual Practices require such. (SDM)
Sep 11, 2026
Your proposed summons was not issued for one of the following reasons: No summons provided, please submit summons. The event can be found under the event Other Documents - Proposed Summons/Civil Cover Sheet., Please correct and resubmit using Proposed Summons/Civil Cover Sheet. (SDM)
Sep 11, 2026
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE and Electronic Service upon the US Attorney's Office re ECF No. 1 Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus, filed by Ruben Lucas. The United States Attorney, as attorney for Respondents, is directed to show cause by 4:00 p.m. on September 16, 2026, in writing, why the petition should not be granted, and why Respondents should not be ordered to immediately release Petitioner from detention. Alternatively, the government may waive its rights to a response and submit a letter or otherwise consent to Petitioner's release without prejudice to its rights on appeal.If the government chooses to file a response, counsel for Respondents must serve a copy of the response on Petitioner, with proof of such service to the Clerk of this Court. As part of its response, the government is directed to file, under seal, if necessary, any records, documents, or other information in Petitioner's immigration file, as well as any underlying records relied upon in its submission not yet filed by Petitioner, and records indicating whether any property was seized from Petitioner at the time of arrest.If the government files a response, Petitioner is directed to file his reply, if any, by 4:00 p.m. on September 18, 2026, with proof of service.Service of a copy of this order, together with a copy of the petition, will be made by the Clerk of this Court through the electronic case filing system to the United States Attorney.To preserve the Court's jurisdiction pending a ruling on the petition, Petitioner shall not be removed from the United States unless and until the Court orders otherwise. See, e.g., Kuprashvili v. Flanagan, No. 25-cv-5268, 2025 WL 2382059 (S.D.N.Y. June 30, 2025) (collecting cases staying removal to maintain the status quo). Additionally, in light of Petitioner's interest in participating in further proceedings before this Court and maintaining adequate access to legal counsel throughout these proceedings, Petitioner shall not be transferred to a facility outside of this District or the Southern District of New York. See Samb v. Joyce, No. 25-cv-6373, ECF No. 3 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 4, 2025). Ordered by Judge Hector Gonzalez on 9/11/2026. (PN)
#3
Sep 14, 2026
Proposed Summons. by Ruben Lucas (Bautista-Munoz, Ma. Nessa) (Entered: 09/14/2026)
Main Document:
Proposed Summons/Civil Cover Sheet
#4
Sep 15, 2026
NOTICE of Appearance by Nathan Shi on behalf of Todd Blanche, Kenneth Genalo, Markwayne Mullin, David Venturella (aty to be noticed) (Shi, Nathan) (Entered: 09/15/2026)
Main Document:
Notice of Appearance
#5
Sep 16, 2026
RESPONSE TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE by Todd Blanche, Kenneth Genalo, Markwayne Mullin, David Venturella, Warden of Metropolitan Detention Center (Brooklyn) (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Alexander Thompson, # 2 Ex. A to Decl., # 3 Ex. B to Decl., # 4 Ex. C to Decl., # 5 Ex. D to Decl., # 6 Ex. E to Decl., # 7 Ex. F to Decl., # 8 Ex. G to Decl., # 9 Ex. H to Decl., # 10 Ex. I to Decl., # 11 Ex. J to Decl., # 12 Ex. K to Decl.) (Shi, Nathan) (Entered: 09/16/2026)
Main Document:
Response to Order to Show Cause
#6
Sep 16, 2026
Letter supplementing Respondents' Response regarding property receipts by Todd Blanche, Kenneth Genalo, Markwayne Mullin, David Venturella, Warden of Metropolitan Detention Center (Brooklyn) (Attachments: # 1 Appendix A) (Shi, Nathan) (Entered: 09/16/2026)
Main Document:
Letter
#7
Sep 16, 2026
Summons Issued as to Defendants Todd Blanche, Kenneth Genalo, Markwayne Mullin, David Venturella, Warden of Metropolitan Detention Center (Brooklyn), U.S. Attorney and U.S. Attorney General. (CCF) (Entered: 09/16/2026)
Main Document:
Summons Issued as to USA
#8
Sep 18, 2026
REPLY in Opposition filed by Ruben Lucas. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit) (Bautista-Munoz, Ma. Nessa) (Entered: 09/18/2026)
Main Document:
Reply in Opposition
Sep 29, 2026
ORDER DISMISSING CASE: On August 28, 2026, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement ("ICE") arrested Petitioner after he appeared for a scheduled immigration check-in. See ECF No. 1 para. 5; ECF No. 5 at 2. Petitioner was ultimately transferred to the Metropolitan Detention Center ("MDC") in Brooklyn, New York, where he remains detained. He now seeks a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2241. ECF No. 1 ("Petition"). For the reasons that follow, his Petition is DISMISSED. BACKGROUNDPetitioner is a citizen of Belize who entered the United States without inspection or admission on October 6, 2024. ECF No. 1 paras. 17, 19; ECF No. 5 at 1. That same day, he was detained by a U.S. Customs and Border Patrol ("CBP") agent and transported to a processing center in Rio Grande Valley for further processing. ECF No. 5 at 1. On October 8, 2024, Petitioner was given a credible fear interview with an asylum officer that resulted in a negative determination. Id. And within a week, Petitioner had the opportunity to appear before an Immigration Judge, who affirmed the asylum officer's negative determination. Id. In the same month, CBP agents released Petitioner on his own recognizance and put him in removal proceedings. Id. at 2; ECF No. 1 para. 29. On November 13, 2025, Petitioner appeared before an Immigration Court for a master calendar hearing. ECF No. 5 at 2. At that hearing, the Immigration Judge found that Petitioner was removable from the United States and granted Petitioner's request for voluntary departure. See id.; ECF No. 1 para. 30. His voluntary departure period expired on March 24, 2026. ECF No. 5 at 2. Petitioner failed to depart by that date even though his wife and daughter voluntarily departed on March 18, 2026, and Petitioner was supposed to depart with them. Id. As a result, on March 25, 2026, Petitioner became subject to a final order of removal. Id. On August 28, 2026, ICE arrested Petitioner after he appeared for a scheduled immigration check-in. See ECF No. 1 para. 5. He was ultimately transferred to MDC in Brooklyn, New York, where he remains detained. Id. para 17; ECF No. 5 at 3. The government asserts that "Petitioner has been detained pursuant to 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(6) for the purpose of effectuating his order of removal." ECF No. 5 at 3.LEGAL STANDARD"The writ of habeas corpus stands as a safeguard against imprisonment of those held in violation of the law." Harrington v. Richter, 562 U.S. 86, 91 (2011); see also Ozturk v. Hyde, 136 F.4th 382, 393 (2d Cir. 2025). A petition for a writ of habeas corpus under Section 2241, "authorizes a district court to grant a writ of habeas corpus whenever a petitioner is 'in custody in violation of the Constitution or laws or treaties of the United States.'" Wang v. Ashcroft, 320 F.3d 130, 140 (2d Cir. 2003) (quoting 28 U.S.C. § 2241(c)). "Federal courts have jurisdiction to hear habeas corpus claims by non-citizens challenging the constitutionality of their detention." Lopez v. Sessions, No. 18-cv-4189, 2018 WL 2932726, at *6 (S.D.N.Y. June 12, 2018) (citing Demore v. Kim, 538 U.S. 510, 516-17 (2003)).DISCUSSIONPetitioner seeks habeas relief because, in his words, his "continued detention without meaningful custody review violates the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment." ECF No. 1 para. 53. The government argues that the Court lacks jurisdiction over the Petition because it is, "in substance, a challenge to the Petitioner's final order of removal, and, therefore, is barred because Congress has enacted jurisdiction-stripping statutes that preclude the district courts from hearing challenges to the validity of a final order of removal." ECF No. 5 at 3. The Court agrees with the government. The REAL ID Act of 2005 amended the immigration laws to strip district courts of jurisdiction over habeas corpus petitions that challenge orders of removal. See Delgado v. Quarantillo, 643 F.3d 52, 54 (2d Cir. 2011). 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(5) gives courts of appeals exclusive jurisdiction over review of final orders of removal. By doing so, Section 1252(a)(5) "clearly preclude[s]" district courts from reviewing direct challenges to removal orders. See Delgado, 643 F.3d at 55. Moreover, 8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(9) states that "[j]udicial review of all questions of law and fact" arising from removal proceedings "shall be available only in judicial review of a final order under this section." It further states that "no court shall have jurisdiction" to review "such questions of law or fact." 8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(9). Thus, taking Sections 1252(a)(5) and (b)(9) together, they "channel all challenges to removal orders and removal proceedings to the courts of appeals." Asylum Seeker Advoc. Project v. Barr, 409 F. Supp. 3d 221, 224 (S.D.N.Y. 2019). Practically, this "mean[s] that any issue -- whether legal or factual -- arising from any removal-related activity can be reviewed only through a petition for review filed with an appropriate court of appeals." Id. (quoting J.E.F.M. v. Lynch, 837 F.3d 1026, 1031 (9th Cir. 2016) (emphasis in original)). Moreover, the Second Circuit interprets this statute expansively, so as to preclude district courts from reviewing "indirect" challenges to removal orders. See Delgado, 643 F.3d at 55. Of course, not every suit brought against immigration authorities is a per se challenge to a removal order. Id. Indeed, "whether the district court has jurisdiction will turn on the substance of the relief that a plaintiff is seeking." Id.Consistent with the Second Circuit's interpretation of Section 1252, courts within this Circuit "have dismissed a wide variety of indirect challenges to removal orders for lack of jurisdiction." Asylum Seeker, 409 F. Supp. 3d at 225 (collecting cases); see also, e.g., Villatoro v. Shanahan, No. 26-cv-1210, 2026 WL 948297, at *3 (E.D.N.Y. Apr. 7, 2026) (denying habeas relief due to lack of subject matter jurisdiction over petition seeking release "from mandatory detention" because "petitioner is making an indirect challenge to the removal order," and release "would frustrate the government's ability to enforce the removal order"); Sauceda Henriquez v. Noem, No. 25-cv-7023, 2026 WL 111665, at *4 (E.D.N.Y. Jan. 15, 2026) (denying habeas relief because "a challenge to a petitioner's detention, following an order of removal, constitutes such an indirect challenge to an order of removal" that is precluded by §§ 1252(a)(5) and (b)(9)); Lin v. Borgen, No. 25-cv-5618, 2025 WL 2158874, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. July 30, 2025) ("Petitioner's request to release him from his current detention and stay his removal is, in sum and substance, a challenge to his final order of removal.... This Court cannot entertain the Petition under the plain language of § 1252."). Here, the government argues that Petitioner's request for release is jurisdictionally barred by Section 1252 because "Petitioner is subject to a final order of removal" and [h]e is being held for the purpose of effectuating the removal order." ECF No. 5 at 7; see also 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a) (governing the detention, release, and removal of individuals subject to final orders of removal). The Court finds, and Petitioner does not dispute, that the removal order at issue here is final. See ECF No. 1 paras. 4, 10, 25, 31, 43-44, 72 (acknowledging that Petitioner "became subject to a final order of removal" following the expiration of his voluntary departure period); ECF No. 8 at 1 (same). The Court further finds that based on the "substance of the relief" sought, Petitioner is indirectly challenging his order of removal. See Delgado, 643 F.3d at 55 ("[W]hether the district court has jurisdiction will turn on the substance of the relief that a plaintiff is seeking."). The specific relief he seeks involves an order requiring the government "to release Petitioner immediately under appropriate conditions or supervision," or, alternatively, order the government "to provide Petitioner with an individualized custody hearing before a neutral decisionmaker within a specified period." ECF No. 1 at 11. In other words, because Petitioner is detained pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1231, by seeking release from mandatory detention, he seeks to frustrate the government's ability to enforce the removal order and is indirectly challenging the final removal order. See Shanahan, 2026 WL 948297, at *3 (collecting cases). Put simply, his request that the Court release him from detention or, in the alternative, provide him with an individualized custody hearing, is "removal-related activity." Asylum Seeker, 409 F. Supp. 3d at 224. No matter how one characterizes Petitioner's request, the Court does not have jurisdiction to grant the relief he seeks. Id.CONCLUSIONFor these reasons, the petition for a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2241 is DISMISSED for lack of jurisdiction. Accordingly, the Court vacates its prior order prohibiting the government from removing Petitioner from the United States or transferring Petitioner to a facility outside of this District or the Southern District of New York. See Sept. 11, 2026, Text Order.The Clerk of Court is respectfully directed to enter judgment consistent with this Order and close this case. Ordered by Judge Hector Gonzalez on 9/29/2026. (SM)
Sep 29, 2026
ORDER DISMISSING CASE: On August 28, 2026, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement ("ICE") arrested Petitioner after he appeared for a scheduled immigration check-in. See ECF No. 1 para. 5; ECF No. 5 at 2. Petitioner was ultimately transferred to the Metropolitan Detention Center ("MDC") in Brooklyn, New York, where he remains detained. He now seeks a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2241. ECF No. 1 ("Petition"). For the reasons that follow, his Petition is DISMISSED. BACKGROUNDPetitioner is a citizen of Belize who entered the United States without inspection or admission on October 6, 2024. ECF No. 1 paras. 17, 19; ECF No. 5 at 1. That same day, he was detained by a U.S. Customs and Border Patrol ("CBP") agent and transported to a processing center in Rio Grande Valley for further processing. ECF No. 5 at 1. On October 8, 2024, Petitioner was given a credible fear interview with an asylum officer that resulted in a negative determination. Id. And within a week, Petitioner had the opportunity to appear before an Immigration Judge, who affirmed the asylum officer's negative determination. Id. In the same month, CBP agents released Petitioner on his own recognizance and put him in removal proceedings. Id. at 2; ECF No. 1 para. 29. On November 13, 2025, Petitioner appeared before an Immigration Court for a master calendar hearing. ECF No. 5 at 2. At that hearing, the Immigration Judge found that Petitioner was removable from the United States and granted Petitioner's request for voluntary departure. See id.; ECF No. 1 para. 30. His voluntary departure period expired on March 24, 2026. ECF No. 5 at 2. Petitioner failed to depart by that date even though his wife and daughter voluntarily departed on March 18, 2026, and Petitioner was supposed to depart with them. Id. As a result, on March 25, 2026, Petitioner became subject to a final order of removal. Id. On August 28, 2026, ICE arrested Petitioner after he appeared for a scheduled immigration check-in. See ECF No. 1 para. 5. He was ultimately transferred to MDC in Brooklyn, New York, where he remains detained. Id. para 17; ECF No. 5 at 3. The government asserts that "Petitioner has been detained pursuant to 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(6) for the purpose of effectuating his order of removal." ECF No. 5 at 3.LEGAL STANDARD"The writ of habeas corpus stands as a safeguard against imprisonment of those held in violation of the law." Harrington v. Richter, 562 U.S. 86, 91 (2011); see also Ozturk v. Hyde, 136 F.4th 382, 393 (2d Cir. 2025). A petition for a writ of habeas corpus under Section 2241, "authorizes a district court to grant a writ of habeas corpus whenever a petitioner is 'in custody in violation of the Constitution or laws or treaties of the United States.'" Wang v. Ashcroft, 320 F.3d 130, 140 (2d Cir. 2003) (quoting 28 U.S.C. § 2241(c)). "Federal courts have jurisdiction to hear habeas corpus claims by non-citizens challenging the constitutionality of their detention." Lopez v. Sessions, No. 18-cv-4189, 2018 WL 2932726, at *6 (S.D.N.Y. June 12, 2018) (citing Demore v. Kim, 538 U.S. 510, 516-17 (2003)).DISCUSSIONPetitioner seeks habeas relief because, in his words, his "continued detention without meaningful custody review violates the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment." ECF No. 1 para. 53. The government argues that the Court lacks jurisdiction over the Petition because it is, "in substance, a challenge to the Petitioner's final order of removal, and, therefore, is barred because Congress has enacted jurisdiction-stripping statutes that preclude the district courts from hearing challenges to the validity of a final order of removal." ECF No. 5 at 3. The Court agrees with the government. The REAL ID Act of 2005 amended the immigration laws to strip district courts of jurisdiction over habeas corpus petitions that challenge orders of removal. See Delgado v. Quarantillo, 643 F.3d 52, 54 (2d Cir. 2011). 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(5) gives courts of appeals exclusive jurisdiction over review of final orders of removal. By doing so, Section 1252(a)(5) "clearly preclude[s]" district courts from reviewing direct challenges to removal orders. See Delgado, 643 F.3d at 55. Moreover, 8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(9) states that "[j]udicial review of all questions of law and fact" arising from removal proceedings "shall be available only in judicial review of a final order under this section." It further states that "no court shall have jurisdiction" to review "such questions of law or fact." 8 U.S.C. § 1252(b)(9). Thus, taking Sections 1252(a)(5) and (b)(9) together, they "channel all challenges to removal orders and removal proceedings to the courts of appeals." Asylum Seeker Advoc. Project v. Barr, 409 F. Supp. 3d 221, 224 (S.D.N.Y. 2019). Practically, this "mean[s] that any issue -- whether legal or factual -- arising from any removal-related activity can be reviewed only through a petition for review filed with an appropriate court of appeals." Id. (quoting J.E.F.M. v. Lynch, 837 F.3d 1026, 1031 (9th Cir. 2016) (emphasis in original)). Moreover, the Second Circuit interprets this statute expansively, so as to preclude district courts from reviewing "indirect" challenges to removal orders. See Delgado, 643 F.3d at 55. Of course, not every suit brought against immigration authorities is a per se challenge to a removal order. Id. Indeed, "whether the district court has jurisdiction will turn on the substance of the relief that a plaintiff is seeking." Id.Consistent with the Second Circuit's interpretation of Section 1252, courts within this Circuit "have dismissed a wide variety of indirect challenges to removal orders for lack of jurisdiction." Asylum Seeker, 409 F. Supp. 3d at 225 (collecting cases); see also, e.g., Villatoro v. Shanahan, No. 26-cv-1210, 2026 WL 948297, at *3 (E.D.N.Y. Apr. 7, 2026) (denying habeas relief due to lack of subject matter jurisdiction over petition seeking release "from mandatory detention" because "petitioner is making an indirect challenge to the removal order," and release "would frustrate the government's ability to enforce the removal order"); Sauceda Henriquez v. Noem, No. 25-cv-7023, 2026 WL 111665, at *4 (E.D.N.Y. Jan. 15, 2026) (denying habeas relief because "a challenge to a petitioner's detention, following an order of removal, constitutes such an indirect challenge to an order of removal" that is precluded by §§ 1252(a)(5) and (b)(9)); Lin v. Borgen, No. 25-cv-5618, 2025 WL 2158874, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. July 30, 2025) ("Petitioner's request to release him from his current detention and stay his removal is, in sum and substance, a challenge to his final order of removal.... This Court cannot entertain the Petition under the plain language of § 1252."). Here, the government argues that Petitioner's request for release is jurisdictionally barred by Section 1252 because "Petitioner is subject to a final order of removal" and [h]e is being held for the purpose of effectuating the removal order." ECF No. 5 at 7; see also 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a) (governing the detention, release, and removal of individuals subject to final orders of removal). The Court finds, and Petitioner does not dispute, that the removal order at issue here is final. See ECF No. 1 paras. 4, 10, 25, 31, 43-44, 72 (acknowledging that Petitioner "became subject to a final order of removal" following the expiration of his voluntary departure period); ECF No. 8 at 1 (same). The Court further finds that based on the "substance of the relief" sought, Petitioner is indirectly challenging his order of removal. See Delgado, 643 F.3d at 55 ("[W]hether the district court has jurisdiction will turn on the substance of the relief that a plaintiff is seeking."). The specific relief he seeks involves an order requiring the government "to release Petitioner immediately under appropriate conditions or supervision," or, alternatively, order the government "to provide Petitioner with an individualized custody hearing before a neutral decisionmaker within a specified period." ECF No. 1 at 11. In other words, because Petitioner is detained pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1231, by seeking release from mandatory detention, he seeks to frustrate the government's ability to enforce the removal order and is indirectly challenging the final removal order. See Shanahan, 2026 WL 948297, at *3 (collecting cases). Put simply, his request that the Court release him from detention or, in the alternative, provide him with an individualized custody hearing, is "removal-related activity." Asylum Seeker, 409 F. Supp. 3d at 224. No matter how one characterizes Petitioner's request, the Court does not have jurisdiction to grant the relief he seeks. Id.CONCLUSIONFor these reasons, the petition for a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2241 is DISMISSED for lack of jurisdiction. Accordingly, the Court vacates its prior order prohibiting the government from removing Petitioner from the United States or transferring Petitioner to a facility outside of this District or the Southern District of New York. See Sept. 11, 2026, Text Order.The Clerk of Court is respectfully directed to enter judgment consistent with this Order and close this case. Ordered by Judge Hector Gonzalez on 9/29/2026. (SM)
Sep 29, 2026
Order Dismissing Case
#9
Sep 30, 2026
CLERK's JUDGMENT: judgment is entered in favor of Defendants. Signed by Deputy Clerk, Ryan Richards, on behalf of Clerk of Court, Brenna B. Mahoney, on 09/30/2026. (ROLR) (Entered: 09/30/2026)
Main Document:
Judgment - Clerk
Parties
Party
Party
Party
Party
Party
Attorney
Attorney